Best Italian Food in New York City

New York City is a melting pot of cultures, and its culinary scene reflects this diversity. Among the many cuisines that have found a home in the Big Apple, Italian food stands out as one of the most beloved and authentic. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pizza, a plate of perfectly cooked pasta, or a mouthwatering tiramisu, New York City has it all. In this gastronomic journey, we'll explore the best Italian restaurants in the city, each offering a delightful taste of Italy's rich culinary heritage. Get ready to savor the flavors of Italy in the heart of New York City!

Best Italian Food in New York City

The Italian Culinary Odyssey

The Italian Influence in NYC

Italian immigrants have played a significant role in shaping New York City's cultural fabric, and their culinary traditions continue to be a cherished part of the city's identity. Italian food, known for its simplicity and quality ingredients, has found a special place in the hearts of New Yorkers.

What to Expect in this Guide

In this guide, we'll take you on a delectable journey through the best Italian restaurants in New York City. From modern Italian elegance to classic pizzerias and hidden gems, you'll discover a range of dining experiences that celebrate Italy's culinary heritage.

L'Artusi: Modern Italian Elegance Best Italian Food in New York City

A Fusion of Tradition and Innovation

L'Artusi is a contemporary Italian restaurant that effortlessly blends traditional flavors with modern culinary techniques. The menu features seasonal ingredients and inventive preparations that pay homage to Italian cuisine.

Must-Try Dishes

• Garganelli: Hand-rolled pasta with mushrooms and thyme.
• Olive Oil Cake: A delightful dessert with citrus and mascarpone.

The Perfect Pairings

L'Artusi's wine list is extensive, with a focus on Italian selections. The knowledgeable staff can recommend the perfect wine pairing to complement your meal.

Roberta's: Brooklyn's Pizza Haven Best Italian Food in New York City

Pizza Perfection

Roberta's, located in the heart of Brooklyn, is renowned for its wood-fired pizzas. The restaurant's dedication to sourcing the finest ingredients results in pizzas that are both simple and sublime.

Beyond Pizza: Other Delights

While pizza is the star of the show, Roberta's also offers an array of delectable small plates, house-made bread, and inventive cocktails.

A Hip and Lively Vibe

The restaurant's vibrant atmosphere and communal seating make it a favorite among Brooklynites and visitors alike.

Carbone: Classic Italian-American Charm

A Nostalgic Journey

Carbone transports diners to a bygone era with its classic Italian-American fare and retro ambiance. The restaurant pays homage to the red-sauce joints of yesteryear.

Timeless Favorites

Indulge in Italian-American classics like spaghetti and meatballs, chicken scarpariello, and veal parmesan.

The Vintage Experience Best Italian Food in New York City

Carbone's old-school charm, complete with black-and-white checkered floors and tuxedoed servers, adds to the sense of nostalgia.

Marea: Coastal Italian Sophistication

From the Sea to Your Plate

Marea is known for its exquisite seafood offerings, showcasing the flavors of the Italian coast. The menu features a wide array of fresh fish and shellfish prepared with precision.

An Exquisite Seafood Experience

Don't miss the opportunity to savor dishes like the famous lobster and burrata or the crudo tasting menu, a celebration of raw seafood.

A Wine Lover's Paradise

Marea's extensive wine list, with a focus on Italian and American selections, perfectly complements the seafood-centric menu.

Lucali: The Art of Simple Pizza

A Pizza Lover's Dream

Lucali's pizza is a testament to the beauty of simplicity. The restaurant offers a limited menu, focusing on perfectly crafted pies with minimal toppings.

The Magic of Simplicity Best Italian Food in New York City

The dough, sauce, and cheese are of the highest quality, creating a pizza that needs no embellishment.

The Eternal Line

Be prepared to wait in line at this beloved pizzeria, but rest assured, the experience is worth it.

L'Artigiano: Hidden Gem of Pasta

Handcrafted Pasta Excellence

L'Artigiano is a hidden gem for pasta enthusiasts. The restaurant prides itself on handcrafting every pasta dish to perfection.

The Art of Italian Simplicity

Experience the pure flavors of Italy with dishes like pappardelle with wild boar ragu or cacio e pepe.

A Cozy Retreat Best Italian Food in New York City

L'Artigiano's intimate setting and welcoming staff create a warm and inviting atmosphere for a memorable dining experience.

Patsy's Italian Restaurant: A Taste of History

A Sinatra Favorite

Patsy's has a storied history as a favorite dining spot of Frank Sinatra. The restaurant has been serving classic Italian-American dishes for generations.

Classic Italian-American Fare Best Italian Food in New York City

Indulge in dishes like veal marsala, eggplant parmigiana, and the famous Patsy's meatballs.

A Timeless NYC Icon

Patsy's rich history and enduring appeal make it a must-visit for those seeking a taste of New York's Italian-American heritage.

Il Buco: Mediterranean Italian Charm

Mediterranean Flavors in Manhattan

Il Buco offers a Mediterranean-inspired take on Italian cuisine. The restaurant's rustic and inviting atmosphere adds to the dining experience.

A Rustic, Yet Refined Atmosphere

Il Buco's decor features antique furnishings and exposed brick walls, creating a cozy ambiance.

Sustainably Sourced Delights Best Italian Food in New York City

The restaurant's commitment to sustainability is reflected in its use of locally sourced and organic ingredients.

Levante: A Sicilian Culinary Escape Best Italian Food in New York City

The Sicilian Influence

Levante brings the flavors of Sicily to the heart of New York City. The restaurant's Sicilian-inspired dishes showcase the island's culinary traditions.

Authenticity and Warmth

The warm and welcoming atmosphere at Levante makes diners feel like they've stepped into a Sicilian home.

Exquisite Sicilian Fare Best Italian Food in New York City

Don't miss out on Sicilian specialties like arancini, caponata, and cannoli for dessert.

Eataly NYC Flatiron: Italian Food Wonderland

Italy Under One Roof

Eataly NYC Flatiron is a culinary wonderland that brings the best of Italy to Manhattan. It's a marketplace, a dining destination, and an educational experience rolled into one.

The Marketplace

Explore a vast selection of Italian products, from artisanal cheeses to freshly baked bread and pastries.

Dining Experiences Galore Best Italian Food in New York City

Eataly offers multiple restaurants and food counters, each specializing in different aspects of Italian cuisine, including pasta, pizza, seafood, and more.

Buon Appetito!

New York City's Italian food scene is a testament to the enduring appeal of this beloved cuisine. From contemporary interpretations to classic comfort food, the city offers a diverse array of Italian dining experiences. Whether you're a local seeking your next favorite spot or a visitor eager to taste the flavors of Italy, you're sure to find satisfaction in the rich and flavorful world of Italian cuisine in New York City. Buon appetito!